In the vast sea of television content available today, it can be easy to overlook hidden gems. While major blockbuster shows often steal the spotlight, there are countless underrated TV shows that deserve just as much attention. These shows may not have received the same level of mainstream recognition, but they feature exceptional storytelling, outstanding performances, and unique premises that will keep you hooked from start to finish.
Whether you’re looking for comedy, drama, or something in between, the world of television is filled with underappreciated series that are worth exploring. In this article, we will highlight some of the most underrated TV shows that you need to watch, each offering something special and memorable in its own right.
“The Leftovers” (2014–2017)
“The Leftovers” is one of those shows that left viewers with a mix of confusion, awe, and deep introspection. Created by Damon Lindelof and Tom Perrotta, the show is set in a world where 2% of the population mysteriously disappears without explanation. The survivors are left grappling with the inexplicable event, leading to a haunting exploration of grief, belief, and existential questions.
While the show initially flew under the radar, “The Leftovers” has since gained a cult following for its emotional depth, strong performances, and philosophical themes. The show’s exploration of loss and the human condition is done with an intensity and subtlety that makes it one of the most thought-provoking dramas of the 21st century. Justin Theroux, Carrie Coon, and Christopher Eccleston deliver standout performances that elevate this series into something truly unique.
If you’re looking for a show that blends mystery, psychological drama, and spiritual exploration, then “The Leftovers” is a must-watch.
“Pushing Daisies” (2007–2009)
“Pushing Daisies” is a whimsical, visually stunning show that mixes mystery, romance, and dark comedy in a way that few series ever have. Created by Bryan Fuller, the series follows Ned, a pie maker with the ability to bring the dead back to life with a touch. However, there’s a catch—he can only keep them alive for a minute before they must die again. This leads him to solve murder mysteries with his partner, Chuck, who, after being brought back to life, becomes the object of his affection.
With its eccentric characters, colorful visuals, and quirky dialogue, “Pushing Daisies” quickly became a fan favorite, but it never garnered the broad mainstream success it deserved. The show’s charm lies in its ability to balance lighthearted moments with mournful themes, creating a narrative that is both beautiful and bittersweet. Lee Pace, Anna Friel, and Chi McBride shine in their roles, bringing the whimsical world to life in a way that few shows manage to do.
If you’re looking for something that’s visually captivating and unlike anything you’ve seen before, “Pushing Daisies” is a show that will stay with you long after it ends.
“Halt and Catch Fire” (2014–2017)
Set during the tech boom of the 1980s and 1990s, “Halt and Catch Fire” offers a fascinating look at the rise of the personal computer industry. The series focuses on a group of innovators and entrepreneurs as they navigate the cutthroat world of Silicon Valley, attempting to shape the future of technology while dealing with their own personal demons.
Despite its critical acclaim and impressive performances from Lee Pace, Mackenzie Davis, and Scoot McNairy, “Halt and Catch Fire” never gained a massive audience, making it one of the most underrated dramas of the last decade. The show is often compared to Mad Men, but it offers a unique perspective on the technology industry, particularly focusing on the pioneers of computing who don’t always get the recognition they deserve.
With its engaging character arcs, compelling plotlines, and historical context, “Halt and Catch Fire” is a must-watch for fans of tech-driven narratives and character-driven drama.
“Terriers” (2010)
Despite being widely praised by critics, “Terriers” was criminally underappreciated and only lasted one season before being canceled. The series follows Hank Dolworth, a disgraced former cop turned private investigator, as he navigates the seedy underbelly of California’s coastal town. The show is a dark, witty mix of crime, drama, and comedy, with Donal Logue delivering an unforgettable performance as the flawed, yet deeply likeable, Hank.
What makes “Terriers” so unique is its perfect balance of gritty crime storytelling and character-driven moments. The show delves into themes of redemption, friendship, and the consequences of one’s past actions. While it was too soon canceled, it remains a gem of modern television, with a small but devoted fanbase who continues to appreciate its nuanced storytelling and powerful performances.
If you’re a fan of neo-noir with humor and heart, “Terriers” should definitely be on your watchlist.
“The Fall” (2013–2016)
If you love psychological thrillers with strong performances, “The Fall” is a hidden gem that is too often overlooked. Starring Gillian Anderson as Stella Gibson, a detective investigating a serial killer in Belfast, the show takes a slow-burn approach to its tension-filled narrative. Jamie Dornan, in his breakout role before “Fifty Shades of Grey”, plays the killer, Paul Spector, a complex and chilling character who keeps the audience on edge.
The show is gripping not just for its whodunit mystery, but also for its deep dive into the psychology of both the detective and the killer. The chemistry between Anderson and Dornan is electric, making for a tense and riveting viewing experience. While the show did not reach the mass popularity of other crime thrillers, its layered character studies and methodical pacing have earned it a place as one of the best underrated crime dramas in recent memory.
For fans of dark, cerebral thrillers with strong female leads, “The Fall” is an absolute must-see.
“Rectify” (2013–2016)
“Rectify” is a profound and emotionally charged drama that explores the life of Daniel Holden, who has spent 19 years on death row for a crime he may not have committed. After his conviction is overturned, Daniel returns to his small town and attempts to reintegrate into society while dealing with the trauma of his past and the suspicions of those around him.
What makes “Rectify” stand out is its quiet, introspective storytelling. It’s a slow burn, focusing on character development and the emotional complexities of Daniel’s journey as he attempts to reconcile with his family, friends, and his own conscience. The show is deeply human and explores themes of justice, forgiveness, and the consequences of trauma.
Aden Young’s performance as Daniel is exceptional, bringing an extraordinary level of nuance and vulnerability to the character. While “Rectify” never gained widespread attention, it is widely regarded as one of the most poignant dramas of the last decade. It’s a show that deserves more recognition for its emotional depth and masterful storytelling.
“Hannibal” (2013–2015)
Based on Thomas Harris‘s novels, “Hannibal” is a psychological thriller that takes a unique approach to the story of Dr. Hannibal Lecter, the infamous psychiatrist and cannibalistic serial killer. The show focuses on the complex relationship between Lecter, portrayed by Mads Mikkelsen, and Will Graham, a gifted FBI profiler played by Hugh Dancy.
What sets “Hannibal” apart from other crime dramas is its artful cinematography, surreal imagery, and exploration of the psychological tension between its two central characters. The show is visually stunning, with highly stylized, often grotesque scenes that push the boundaries of what’s acceptable on network television.
Despite being critically acclaimed for its performances and unique tone, “Hannibal” struggled to find a large audience, leading to its premature cancellation after three seasons. However, the show has maintained a cult following, with fans praising its intellectual approach to the thriller genre. If you’re a fan of dark psychological dramas, “Hannibal” should definitely be on your radar.
“Banshee” (2013–2016)
“Banshee” is a high-octane crime drama that takes place in a small town in Pennsylvania, where Lucas Hood, an ex-convict, assumes the identity of the town’s sheriff. The series is known for its action-packed sequences, intricate plot twists, and dark humor, as well as its exploration of loyalty, revenge, and redemption.
The show combines elements of gangster drama, action, and thriller, with a focus on the complex relationships between its characters. The performances from Antony Starr, Ivana Milicevic, and Ulrich Thomsen are solid, bringing depth to the otherwise action-heavy narrative.
Though it was often overshadowed by other high-profile crime dramas, “Banshee” developed a loyal fan base due to its thrilling pace, brutal action scenes, and unpredictable storytelling. For fans of gritty crime dramas with a heavy dose of adrenaline, “Banshee” is a hidden gem worth watching.
“Fargo” (2014–present)
While Fargo has gained some recognition over the years, it’s often overlooked compared to other highly acclaimed TV series. Inspired by the Coen Brothers’ iconic 1996 film of the same name, the TV adaptation brings its signature blend of dark comedy, crime, and absurdity to the small screen.
The series is set in the Midwest and explores the bizarre lives of individuals caught in crime, corruption, and murder. Each season introduces new characters and a different story while maintaining the quirky, morally complex tone of the original film. With a fantastic ensemble cast that includes Billy Bob Thornton, Ewan McGregor, and Chris Rock, “Fargo” continues to be one of the most unique and imaginative series on television.
“The Terror” (2018–2019)
The Terror is an anthology horror series based on the real-life 1845 Franklin Expedition, which sought to navigate the Northwest Passage. The first season chronicles the doomed journey of the HMS Erebus and HMS Terror, both of which mysteriously disappear, leaving a crew to fend for survival against an unknown threat.
With its eerie atmosphere, historical setting, and chilling narrative, “The Terror” blends historical fiction with supernatural horror, making it a standout in the genre. The first season’s performances, particularly from Jared Harris and Tobias Menzies, combined with stunning cinematography and taut storytelling, make this show an underrated masterpiece that deserves more recognition.
Conclusion
In a television landscape flooded with countless shows, it’s easy for hidden gems to go unnoticed. These underrated TV shows, though often overlooked by mainstream audiences, offer brilliant storytelling, unforgettable characters, and unique perspectives that deserve to be celebrated. Whether you’re looking for dark psychological thrillers, emotional character-driven dramas, or gripping action-packed narratives, these underrated shows offer something for every type of viewer. Dive into these overlooked masterpieces, and you may just find your next favorite series.
